The man in the photos was at the scene during both thefts at the Church of the Epiphany -- on April 14 and again last Wednesday, authorities said.
"The photos are nice and clear," Police Chief Richard Gaito told Daily Voice. "We're hoping someone recognizes him, or he comes in to headquarters. We'd like to speak with him."
Anyone who sees, knows or has information about the man in the photos is asked to contact the Cliffside Park Police Detective Bureau at (201) 313-2085 or the main desk at (201) 945-3600.
The Knox Avenue church celebrated its 100th anniversary last year.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Cliffside Park-Edgewater and receive free news updates.